The protracted copyright infringement class action by freelance writers seeking compensation for pieces published without authorization in various online databases has hit another roadblock.
In re Literary Works in Electronic Databases Copyright Litigation involves claims for infringement of works as to some of which the copyrights are registered and the vast majority are unregistered. This detail – the registered/non-registered distinction – keeps stymieing resolution of the case. In 2007, after the parties had spent years negotiating a settlement and gaining district court approval, the Second Circuit threw out the settlement, holding that the district court lacked subject matter jurisdiction to approve the settlement because many of the claims to be resolved were based on unregistered works, and registration is a jurisdictional predicate to a copyright infringement suit. The Supreme Court finally reversed in 2010, and the parties went back to the district court and again gained approval of the settlement.
